Home › Uncategorized › How Surveillance Supports Workers’ Comp and Liability Claim Defense in Florida

How Surveillance Supports Workers’ Comp and Liability Claim Defense in Florida

Camera with telephoto lens on a car seat overlooking a commercial street at dusk during private investigator surveillance
Share this article
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Email

Practical brief for Florida claims adjusters, TPAs and defense counsel on using surveillance in workers’ compensation and liability claims.

Surveillance helps only when it answers a specific question the file cannot resolve on paper. Aimed well, it gives the claims team and defense counsel a dated record of public activity to compare with the restrictions or injuries being claimed. Aimed poorly, it produces hours of video that never touch the issues in the claim. This brief explains how to aim that work in Florida workers’ compensation files and in general liability or auto claims, and what a usable deliverable looks like.

Short answer

In a Florida workers’ compensation claim, plan surveillance around specific work restrictions or unreported activity. In a liability claim, plan it around the injuries and daily limitations the plaintiff describes. A licensed investigator can document what is visible from lawful vantage points and deliver timestamped video with a written report. MAYN Investigations is licensed and insured (Florida Agency License A3400126), based in Central Florida, and available 24/7.

This is general information, not legal advice. Decisions about claim handling, discovery, privilege and how footage will be used belong to the carrier, counsel and the court.

The question is different in workers’ comp and in liability

The field work can look similar: an investigator watches public activity, keeps a timeline and records what can be recorded lawfully. The assignment should still start from a different question in each type of claim. In workers’ compensation, the comparison is usually to work status and medical restrictions. In a liability claim, including auto and premises cases, the comparison is usually to the damages story: pain, loss of enjoyment, or an inability to work or handle ordinary daily tasks.

A workers’ compensation file that turns on lifting and standing limits needs coverage when those activities are most likely to appear, not a generic request to watch the house. A liability file that turns on daily activities needs a different plan. Our pages on workers’ comp investigations in Florida and insurance defense investigations describe how we scope each kind of assignment.

Workers’ comp: compare activity to the claimed restrictions

The most useful workers’ compensation surveillance starts with a short list of observable claims from the file: the recorded statement, work-status notes or deposition testimony. “Cannot lift more than ten pounds,” “does not drive,” “has not returned to any work” and “cannot stand for long periods” are things an investigator can plan around. A request to “see what is going on” is not.

Common questions include whether the claimant is doing physical activity that appears inconsistent with current restrictions, whether they appear to be working or running a business that has not been reported, and whether public activity lines up with a claimed inability to work a shift. The investigator documents what they see, with dates, times and a clear description. They do not diagnose an injury or decide whether a claim should be denied. Those decisions stay with the adjuster, the physician and counsel.

Some files also need AOE/COE fact-finding: whether the accident arose out of employment and in the course of employment. That work is usually scene documentation, photographs and witness interviews, not a multi-day activity check. If the file needs both, say so at intake. We outline that fact-finding on the workers’ comp investigations page.

Liability claims: document activity against the damages story

In a general liability, auto or premises claim, surveillance is typically aimed at the plaintiff’s current activity, not at reconstructing the accident. Scene work, when it is still possible, is a different assignment and should be requested early; see our brief on premises liability scene investigation in Florida.

Useful assignments identify two or three specific claims, such as no longer able to work, unable to drive, or no longer able to take part in a named household or recreational task. The investigator can then plan coverage around times when those activities, if they are happening, would be visible from a lawful vantage point. Footage of a person walking to a mailbox, without more, rarely answers a damages question. Footage that fairly shows a claimed-impossible task, with context and a timeline, is something counsel can evaluate. Defense firms can review lawful limits and discovery timing in our guide to insurance defense surveillance for Florida defense counsel. This article focuses on aiming the field work itself.

What to send with the assignment

Adjusters, TPA staff and paralegals can start the intake. At minimum, send the claimant’s or plaintiff’s name; a recent photo if one is available; known addresses, vehicles and workplaces; the specific restrictions or daily-activity claims that matter, quoted or closely paraphrased from the records; known schedules such as medical appointments or light-duty shifts; upcoming IME, deposition, mediation or hearing dates; and any safety concerns the field team should know about. Our paralegal checklist for assigning an investigation is a useful starting point. We confirm scope, location and a budget range on a short call before any field time is booked.

Time the field days around the claim

Calendar availability is not the same as useful coverage. If the file turns on whether the claimant can work, a morning of known medical appointments may show very little. If an IME or a deposition is coming up, counsel sometimes wants coverage close to those dates so the activity documented is relevant to what will be said about current limitations. That timing is a claim-handling and legal decision. The investigator’s role is to tell you what can and cannot be covered in the days you have. When the budget supports it, more than one day of coverage is often more informative than a single short window. Planning those days is discussed in planning multi-day surveillance. Disclosure rules in litigation are covered in our insurance defense surveillance guide.

What a usable report should give you

A usable deliverable usually includes timestamped video and photographs of activity visible from a lawful vantage point; a chronological log with dates and times; a written report that separates what the investigator personally observed from background taken from the file; and clear notes on limitations, such as weather, a vehicle that never moved, or identity that could not be confirmed.

The report should not overstate what the video shows. A person carrying a grocery bag is not proof they can return to a medium-duty job. A person who stays indoors all afternoon is not proof they are unable to work. See what a surveillance observation can and cannot show and what makes an investigative report useful to attorneys. The investigator can provide an affidavit or testify about what they personally observed; opinions about medical status belong to the physicians and to counsel.

Florida law also limits how the work can be done. Investigators may observe and record what a person exposes to public view, from places they have a right to be. They should not trespass, and they should not capture private conversations covered by section 934.03. Those limits are described on our surveillance investigations page and in the Florida recording-law guide.

Coverage in Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville and Ocala

MAYN Investigations is based in Central Florida, with our office in Orlando, and takes workers’ compensation and liability surveillance assignments statewide. The same licensed team handles work for a private investigator in Orlando, a private investigator in Tampa, a private investigator in Jacksonville and a private investigator in Ocala. We are available 24/7 at (321) 340-3280.

FAQ: surveillance on Florida workers’ comp and liability claims

When should a Florida adjuster request workers’ comp surveillance?

When the file raises a specific, observable question about current activity or work status that the medical records and statements do not resolve, such as claimed lifting or standing limits, a question about unreported work, or activity around a change in work status.

How is surveillance used differently on a liability claim?

On a liability, auto or premises claim, the comparison is usually to the damages story: what the plaintiff says they can no longer do. Reconstructing the accident itself is a different assignment, typically scene and witness work rather than an activity check.

What should we send to start the assignment?

A recent photo if one is available, known addresses and vehicles, the specific restrictions or daily-activity claims that matter, any known schedule, and upcoming IME, deposition or hearing dates. We confirm scope on a short call before field work begins.

Can coverage be planned around an IME or a deposition?

Yes. Tell us the dates that matter and we will tell you what can be covered around them. Whether to do that, and how any footage will be used, is a decision for the claims team and defense counsel.

Where does MAYN run this work?

We are based in Central Florida, with our office in Orlando, and we take assignments in Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville, Ocala and statewide. Call (321) 340-3280, 24/7.

Talk to an investigator about the claim

If you are a Florida adjuster, TPA or defense attorney preparing a workers’ compensation or liability surveillance assignment, we can review the claimed limitations, the dates and the location, and give you a realistic plan before any field time is booked.

Ready to scope a claim-surveillance assignment?

Call (321) 340-3280 or request a confidential consultation. MAYN Investigations is licensed and insured (Florida Agency License A3400126), based in Central Florida, and available 24/7. Our team includes investigators with military and law enforcement backgrounds. Alexander Maynfeld, Director of Investigations.

Follow us on Instagram at @mayninvestigations. Browse more investigation insights for attorneys.

This article is general information for claims professionals and legal professionals. It is not legal advice, and decisions about claim handling, discovery, privilege, admissibility and legal strategy belong to the carrier and to counsel.

Follow us on Instagram @mayninvestigationsShort field notes and video briefs for Florida attorneys and paralegals. Follow @mayninvestigations
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Email

Need help with a matter like this?

Licensed Florida PI agency (A3400126) supporting attorneys and businesses statewide.

Related Articles