Practical brief for Florida insurance defense attorneys and paralegals who are considering surveillance on a claimant.
Surveillance is one of the most requested assignments in insurance defense, and one of the easiest to waste. A day of video that shows a parked car and a closed front door does not help anyone. A well-scoped assignment, run lawfully and timed around discovery, can give defense counsel something concrete to compare against the claimed limitations. This brief walks through how Florida defense firms can plan that work with a licensed investigator.
Short answer
Insurance defense surveillance in Florida works best when counsel retains a licensed agency, defines the claimed limitations to be observed, and times the field days around deposition and discovery. Investigators may record what is visible from lawful vantage points, but should not trespass, pretext or capture private conversations. MAYN Investigations is licensed and insured and available 24/7.
It is general information, not legal advice. Decisions about discovery, privilege and admissibility belong to counsel and the court.
Start with the claimed limitations, not the address
The most useful surveillance assignments begin with a short list of specific, observable claims taken from the file: the recorded statement, medical records, interrogatory answers or deposition testimony. “Cannot lift more than ten pounds,” “does not drive,” “has not returned to work” and “cannot stand for long periods” are claims an investigator can plan around. “See what he is up to” is not.
When you assign the work, give the investigator the items below (our paralegal checklist for assigning an investigation covers general intake):
- The claimant’s name, a recent photo if one is available, known addresses and vehicles.
- The specific limitations or activities that matter to the defense.
- Known schedules: medical appointments, therapy days, work shifts, school drop-offs or church.
- Upcoming deadlines such as the claimant’s deposition, an IME or mediation.
Know where lawful surveillance stops in Florida
Defense counsel will eventually have to explain how the video was obtained. That explanation is easier when the investigator stayed well inside the lines. In general terms:
- Public vantage points. Investigators can observe and record what a person exposes to public view, from places the investigator has a right to be, such as a public road or a business open to the public.
- No trespass. Florida’s trespass statutes in Chapter 810 apply to investigators like anyone else. Entering fenced or posted property, or a private area of a residence, to get a better angle creates problems for the evidence and for the firm.
- No private conversations. Section 934.03 makes it unlawful to intercept oral communications without the consent of all parties where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. Surveillance video should be planned without capturing private conversations. Our guide to Florida’s recording law, section 934.03, explains the issue in more detail.
- No pretexting into private spaces. Posing as someone else to get inside a home or to obtain protected records invites challenges that can outweigh anything the footage shows.
- Licensing. Surveillance for hire in Florida is regulated under Chapter 493. Confirm the agency and investigators are licensed before the first field day. See Chapter 493 licensing for Florida private investigators, our Florida private investigation law guide, and lawyers’ supervision duties under Florida Bar Rule 4-5.3.
Plan the timing around discovery
The key Florida case on surveillance discovery is Dodson v. Persell, 390 So. 2d 704 (Fla. 1980). In summary, the Florida Supreme Court held that the existence of surveillance materials is discoverable on request; the contents become discoverable if they will be used as evidence, substantively or for impeachment; and, within the trial court’s discretion, the surveilling party may depose the person filmed before producing the contents. Later district court decisions, such as Hankerson v. Wiley (Fla. 4th DCA 2015), have applied that sequencing in personal injury cases.
For planning purposes, that usually means two things. First, surveillance before the claimant’s deposition can be compared against sworn testimony. Second, once surveillance exists, counsel should expect to disclose that it exists when asked. Which strategy fits a particular file is counsel’s call. The investigator’s job is to deliver the work on the schedule counsel sets and to document it so it can be produced cleanly.
Choose the right days and the right amount of coverage
Coverage decisions are where budgets are made or lost. A few practical points:
- Use known schedules. Days with a medical or therapy appointment give a reason for the claimant to leave the residence and a fixed point to start from.
- Mix weekdays and weekends. Errands, recreation and side work often look different on a Saturday.
- Phase the work. One or two days, a short report, then a decision on whether more coverage is justified. Our post on planning multi-day surveillance covers this approach.
What the deliverable should include
Defense counsel needs more than a video file. A usable surveillance package typically includes a time-stamped narrative, original unedited video with preserved metadata, a clear statement of where the investigator was positioned, and the identifying details that tie the person on video to the claimant. Periods with no activity are documented too, because gaps in a log raise questions. Our posts on what a surveillance observation can and cannot show and what makes an investigative report useful to attorneys go further into report quality.
Surveillance coverage in Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville and Ocala
MAYN Investigations is based in Central Florida and handles surveillance for defense firms statewide, covering the Ninth, Thirteenth and Fourth Circuits, among others. See our pages for a private investigator in Orlando, a private investigator in Tampa and a private investigator in Jacksonville, a private investigator in Ocala, along with our full surveillance investigations service and activity and lifestyle surveillance. Law firms can also review our investigative services for attorneys.
For claim-focused assignments, see our insurance defense investigations and workers’ comp investigations in Florida pages.
FAQ: insurance defense surveillance in Florida
Can a private investigator record a claimant in Florida?
Generally, a licensed investigator can record what a person exposes to public view from a lawful vantage point. Investigators should not trespass, enter private areas, or record private conversations covered by section 934.03. Counsel should decide how the footage will be used.
Does the defense have to disclose surveillance?
Under Dodson v. Persell, the existence of surveillance is discoverable on request, and the contents are discoverable if they will be used as evidence. Courts may allow the defense to depose the claimant first. Disclosure strategy is a legal decision for counsel.
Talk to an investigator about your file
If you are a Florida defense attorney or paralegal preparing a surveillance assignment, we can review the claimed limitations, the deadlines and the location, and give you a realistic plan before any field time is booked.
Ready to scope a surveillance assignment?
Call (321) 340-3280 or request a confidential consultation. MAYN Investigations is licensed and insured (Florida Agency License A3400126), based in Central Florida, and available 24/7. Our team includes investigators with military and law enforcement backgrounds. Alexander Maynfeld, Director of Investigations.
Follow us on Instagram at @mayninvestigations. Browse more investigation insights for attorneys.
This article is general information for attorneys and legal professionals. It is not legal advice, and decisions about discovery, privilege, admissibility and legal strategy belong to counsel.

